- Columns - Current and Archives
- Looking Back by Jack Lebo - February 2012 >
- Murphy's Law - July 2013>
- Murphy's Law - May 2013
- Murphy's Law - April 2013
- Murphy's Law - March 2013
- Murphy's Law - February 2013
- Murphy's Law - January 2013
- Murphy's Law - December 2012
- Murphy's Law - November 2012
- Murphy's Law - October 2012
- Murphy's Law - September 2012
- Murphy's Law - August 2012
- Murphy's Law - July 2012
- Murphy's Law - June 2012
- Murphy's Law - May 2012
- Murphy's Law - April 2012
- Murphy's Law - March 2012
- Murphy's Law - February 2012
- Murphy's Law - January 2012
- Murphy's Law - December 2011
- Murphy's Law - November 2011
- Murphy's Law - October 2011
- Murphy's Law - September 2011
- Murphy's Law - August 2011
- Murphy's Law - July 2011
- Murphy's Law - June 2011
- Murphy's Law - May 2011
- Your Money Matters by Thomas Sottile - February 2013>
- Taking Care by Lisa Petsche - May 2013>
- Taking Care - April 2013
- Taking Care - March 2013
- Taking Care - February 2013
- Taking Care - January 2013
- Taking Care - December 2012
- Taking Care - November 2012
- Taking Care - October 2012
- Taking Care - September 2012
- Taking Care - August 2012
- Taking Care - July 2012
- Taking Care - June 2012
- Taking Care - May 2012
- Travel Articles
- There's Much To Like About Tybee Island, Georgia
- PA’s Little Town Of Bethlehem Has Giant History, Pleasant Surprises
- Savannah Style: History, Food, Architecture And Even Ghosts
- Vacationing Beats Back Winter
- Visiting The Inn At Pocono Manor
- Delights of Northern Ireland
- Tuscana Resort near Orlando
- Belfast To Commemorate Titanic
- Protect Your Home While Vacationing
- Nearby Hampton Roads, Virginia
- New 'Heritage' Travel Division Formed
- Lifestyle Articles
- PAE-300 ‘Personal Audio Enhancer’ Brings New Sounds And Clarity To Television
- Seniors Desire To Stay In Home Has Led To Innovative Housing
- ‘Pleasantly Plump’ May Not Pose Serious Health Problems After All
- Spring Hills Brings Home Care, Assisted Living to S. Jersey
- Sense Of Family Obligation Remains Strong
- Becoming Bilingual Thought To Delay Onset Of Cognitive Impairment
- Comprehensive Study Provides Foundation For ‘New American Diet’
- Is Alzheimer's A Myth?
- Living Alone, Without Loneliness
- Chocolate In Moderation
- Expert: Forgiveness, Gratitude Are Essential For Healthy Aging
- Expert: No Limit To Length Of Life
- Media-Based Pennsylvania Veterans Museum Is Historic Treasure
- Joint Task: Take Action To Combat Knee Pain
- Want Better Performance From Portfolio? Watch Congress
- Conscientiousness Key To Longevity
- Men, Women 'Retire' Differently
- Sleep Problems And Cognitive Issues
- Newsworthy
- Binge Drinking Is A National Problem — Even With Senior Citizens
- Study Warns Of High Cardiovascular Disease Risks Of Eating Yolks
- Study: 'Old' People Smell Better
- Depression, Anxiety Are Key Factors In Impact Of Parkinson’s Disease
- Study: Don’t Worry, Be Happy For Better Cardiovascular Health
- ‘Chore Connection’ Provides Unique Services, Volunteer Opportunities
- Study Reinforces Benefits Of Regular Colonoscopies
- Study: 'Senior Moments' Begin Earlier
- Three New Studies Suggest Aspirin May Prevent Some Cancers
- No Sure Bet: Seniors Must Recognize Potential Gambling Problems
- Coping With Grief
- New Recommendation Creates Debate Over Prostate Screening
- High Salt, Low Potassium Diet Linked To Increased Death Risk
- Medical Director At HCR ManorCare Receives APPLE Award
- RomneyCare Awful Lot Like Obamacare
- Grandkids Safer With Gram/Pop At Wheel
- AARP: Recession Hits Seniors Hard
- Antidepressants Can Increase Danger of Falling
- Poll: Low Marks For U.S. Healthcare
- More Good News For Coffee Drinkers
- Book Reviews
- We The People
- The Immortal Life Of Henrietta Lacks
- The Love Of My Youth
- The American Way Of Eating
- ‘Rin Tin Tin’
- Pity The Billionaire
- Classic: Uncle Tom's Cabin
- A Stocking Full Of New Christmas Novels
- When China Rules The World
- The Submission - Amy Waldman
- My Soul's Been Psychedelicized
- Reckless Endangerment
- O'Nan's 'Emily Alone'
- Baseball In The Garden Of Eden
- Leisure / Entertainment
- Music - Donald Fagen's 'Eminent Hipster,' Jimi Hendrix Release
- Music - Two CD-Set Features Elvis In Hawaii; Eric Burdon Has New Release
- Music - Billy Joel's 'Love Songs' Set For Release
- Music - Paul Anka Shows Off His Versatility With Compilation CD Of ‘Duets’
- Music - Elvis, Otis Redding Fans Treated To Compilation Sets
- Music - Even At Age 80, Willie Nelson Flaunts Staying Power With Duets Album
- Music - New 63-CD Set Spans Much Of Johnny Cash's Career
- Music - Preservation Jazz Hall Band Celebrates Anniversary
- Music - New Releases Spotlight Garfunkel, Los Lobos
- Music - Television Pioneer Ernie Kovacs Featured In Two New DVD Releases
- Music - Simon’s ‘Graceland’ Album Celebrated With Anniversary Release
- Music - New Releases of Hathaway, Heart Music
- Music - Willie Nelson Still Producing New Music
- Music - New Release of Elvis' Work
- Music - 'The Sound Of Philadelphia'
- Music - Dave Brubeck, Hank Williams Reissues
- Music - Janis Joplin Showcased On 2 New CD Releases
- Music - Paul Simon, Jimi Hendrix Reissues
- Legal Articles
- Adult Children May Be Left To Pay Nursing Home Costs Of Indigent Parents
- Make A Resolution That Provides Long-Term Security
- Dialogue Helps Control And Direct Legal, Financial & Medical Matters
- Life Changes Can Require Revisions, Updates To Estate Plan
- Wills Create Solid Foundation For Effective Estate Planning
- Keep Or Shred? Know What To Do With Personal, Financial Records
- Recent Court Ruling Makes It ‘Open Season’ On Adult Children In PA
- Assuring For Care Of Your Pet
- Reader Resources
- Links To Government and Social Services
- Senior Discounts / bradsdeals.com
- For Advertisers / 2013
- To Subscribe
- Contact Us
- Submitting Letters To The Editor
New Recommendation Creates Debate Over Prostate Screening
By Grace Wiltbank
Contributing Writer
To take the PSA prostate cancer test or not to take it is the nerve-wracking dilemma now facing middle aged and elderly men.
The dilemma arises from a recent report by the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force — a panel of independent experts — which concluded that healthy men should consider foregoing the long-recommended PSA test (Prostate-Specific-Antigen test) for prostate cancer because the test doesn’t save that many lives and can lead to harmful effects from surgery or other treatments. These ill effects include acute urinary and intestinal problems and erectile dysfunction.
While prostate cancer claims the lives of thousands of American men each year, the Task Force said most prostate cancers are small and very slow growing and thus are rarely fatal. The Task Force recommended “watchful waiting,” that is, regular monitoring by the patient’s doctor rather than PSA screening.
The recommendation that men consider foregoing the test has met with considerable opposition from doctors and others in the medical field.
Dr. Curtis Miyamoto, an oncologist at Temple Hospital, said in a interview in The Philadelphia Inquirer that the new recommendations not to screen “to me are excessive.”
“Part of the reason I say this,” he said, “is because in the U.S. alone there will be almost 25,000 more cases (of prostate cancer) diagnosed this year than last. The incidence is increasing and the result will be more than 33,000 deaths this year.”
Dr. Miyamoto added: “Prostate cancer is not one disease — it comes in a range of stages and aggressiveness. And, it’s wrong to make the blanket statement that men should not be screened knowing that more than 33,000 will die from it (prostate cancer) this year.”
“I admit,” Dr. Miyamota said, “there are excessive screenings for men who will never actually benefit from them, but you cannot make the broad statement that we’re not going to do this (PSA screening) anymore.”
The American Cancer Society, he said, has made the reasonable recommendation that men should be screened starting at age 50. Dr. Miyamota said the risk of prostate cancer is higher when there is a family history of the disease. With respect to ethnic groups, he said, “African Americans have the highest risk — period. That group definitely needs to be screened. And Caucasians are at a higher risk that Asians and Hispanics.”
The doctor said he himself has had the PSA test because “I’m over 50.”
Joseph K. Izes, M.D., of Horsham, PA said in a letter to the editor of The Inquirer that as a urologist he is “gravely concerned” about the Task Force’s new recommendations concerning PSA testing.
Dr. Izes wrote “these recommendations do a great disservice to men, particularly to those with a higher risk of the disease (i.e., African American men, those with a family history of the disease, the underinsured and those with limited healthcare access).” Dr. Izes said the decision to be tested “is an individual decision that men should discuss with their physician. No single standard applies to all men.”
The Prostate Cancer Foundation (PCF) — a leading philanthropic funder of prostate cancer research — issued a statement on Oct. 10 supporting “continued routine PSA screening of informed patients until new American Urological Association clinical guidelines on PSA screening are issued and disseminated.”
PCF said it strongly recommends more research into better early detection tests for prostate cancer.
However, PCF also said that the federal Task Force’s controversial recommendation “heightened awareness...of the issue of severe complications and patient suffering from the over-diagnosis and overtreatment of indolent prostate cancers.”
In addition to the emotional and physical suffering experienced by men and their families, PCF said, “A recent cost-effectiveness analysis of PSA screening estimated that the cost of diagnosis and treatment is over $5,227,306 per patient to prevent one U.S. prostate cancer death.”
Other new developments on the prostate cancer front include reported findings that saw palmetto extract is no more effective than a placebo in treating an enlarged prostate, that selenium and Vitamin E do not ward off the disease, and that in some instances Vitamin E alone can promote prostate cancer.
On the positive side is a study finding that prostate cancer victims who exercise vigorously fare better than patients that don’t.
*
Contributing Writer
To take the PSA prostate cancer test or not to take it is the nerve-wracking dilemma now facing middle aged and elderly men.
The dilemma arises from a recent report by the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force — a panel of independent experts — which concluded that healthy men should consider foregoing the long-recommended PSA test (Prostate-Specific-Antigen test) for prostate cancer because the test doesn’t save that many lives and can lead to harmful effects from surgery or other treatments. These ill effects include acute urinary and intestinal problems and erectile dysfunction.
While prostate cancer claims the lives of thousands of American men each year, the Task Force said most prostate cancers are small and very slow growing and thus are rarely fatal. The Task Force recommended “watchful waiting,” that is, regular monitoring by the patient’s doctor rather than PSA screening.
The recommendation that men consider foregoing the test has met with considerable opposition from doctors and others in the medical field.
Dr. Curtis Miyamoto, an oncologist at Temple Hospital, said in a interview in The Philadelphia Inquirer that the new recommendations not to screen “to me are excessive.”
“Part of the reason I say this,” he said, “is because in the U.S. alone there will be almost 25,000 more cases (of prostate cancer) diagnosed this year than last. The incidence is increasing and the result will be more than 33,000 deaths this year.”
Dr. Miyamoto added: “Prostate cancer is not one disease — it comes in a range of stages and aggressiveness. And, it’s wrong to make the blanket statement that men should not be screened knowing that more than 33,000 will die from it (prostate cancer) this year.”
“I admit,” Dr. Miyamota said, “there are excessive screenings for men who will never actually benefit from them, but you cannot make the broad statement that we’re not going to do this (PSA screening) anymore.”
The American Cancer Society, he said, has made the reasonable recommendation that men should be screened starting at age 50. Dr. Miyamota said the risk of prostate cancer is higher when there is a family history of the disease. With respect to ethnic groups, he said, “African Americans have the highest risk — period. That group definitely needs to be screened. And Caucasians are at a higher risk that Asians and Hispanics.”
The doctor said he himself has had the PSA test because “I’m over 50.”
Joseph K. Izes, M.D., of Horsham, PA said in a letter to the editor of The Inquirer that as a urologist he is “gravely concerned” about the Task Force’s new recommendations concerning PSA testing.
Dr. Izes wrote “these recommendations do a great disservice to men, particularly to those with a higher risk of the disease (i.e., African American men, those with a family history of the disease, the underinsured and those with limited healthcare access).” Dr. Izes said the decision to be tested “is an individual decision that men should discuss with their physician. No single standard applies to all men.”
The Prostate Cancer Foundation (PCF) — a leading philanthropic funder of prostate cancer research — issued a statement on Oct. 10 supporting “continued routine PSA screening of informed patients until new American Urological Association clinical guidelines on PSA screening are issued and disseminated.”
PCF said it strongly recommends more research into better early detection tests for prostate cancer.
However, PCF also said that the federal Task Force’s controversial recommendation “heightened awareness...of the issue of severe complications and patient suffering from the over-diagnosis and overtreatment of indolent prostate cancers.”
In addition to the emotional and physical suffering experienced by men and their families, PCF said, “A recent cost-effectiveness analysis of PSA screening estimated that the cost of diagnosis and treatment is over $5,227,306 per patient to prevent one U.S. prostate cancer death.”
Other new developments on the prostate cancer front include reported findings that saw palmetto extract is no more effective than a placebo in treating an enlarged prostate, that selenium and Vitamin E do not ward off the disease, and that in some instances Vitamin E alone can promote prostate cancer.
On the positive side is a study finding that prostate cancer victims who exercise vigorously fare better than patients that don’t.
*